Let appearance be a consequence of fitness


 
By: Greyson Gilbert*
 
The pursuit of fitness has to begin with a goal. For Military Service Members, the ultimate goal is to successfully complete the mission—whatever that might be. For most people, that mission probably demands a certain level of physical fitness to match their performance needs. This includes passing the fitness test and being held accountable for body-composition standards. Physical training and exercise are huge pieces of the overall mission puzzle. But nutrition is an equally important Total Force Fitness domain for physical—and mental—performance optimization. 
 
A professor once told me that the science of nutrition is as much psychology as it is biology because optimizing nutritional health is all about understanding behavior—the difference between knowing what quality food is and making the right choices. People have different tastes, cultural backgrounds, food histories, and performance goals. 
 
My various objectives, or competitions, I’ve participated in—Crossfit, powerlifting, Ironman, bike racing, etc.—have demanded different body weights and compositions for optimal performance. Through nutrition manipulation, I’ve gained and lost significant amounts of weight throughout the various training seasons—sometimes gaining or losing up to 30 lbs at a time. Recently, for powerlifting, I gained weight and saw my strength increase—I also saw my cardiovascular performance decrease significantly. When I accomplished those goals, I decided to lose some weight, and I committed myself to endurance and Ironman triathlon. 
 

The triathlon (and, in general, endurance) community is a lean one. Individuals tend to be thinner. Elite male Ironman competitors typically have around 6–12% body fat, and females have 15–23%. You don’t want to carry any extra weight for long hours of effort. 
 
Coming from a strength background, I began to feel the pressure to drop weight. Through a specific nutrition strategy (and training), I lost weight fast—too fast, in fact. At my peak, I found that caloric restriction had brought me from a standard 190 lbs to 165 lbs in a short few months.  
 
Although I looked in the mirror and felt like I was becoming a real triathlete, I saw my performance gains plateau. I felt I was doing everything right, but why did I feel tired all the time? By re-evaluating my fueling strategies and overall performance goals, I realized I needed to make a change. 
The crux of the problem was this: Was my goal the appearance of high performance, or was my goal to actually perform at the highest level I could?   
Endurance athletes tend to be lean. I could get into the science of power-to-weight ratio, but if you look at this year’s Ironman Kona World Championship field of competitors, it’s obvious when you see how lean they are:  For elite competitors, body composition isn’t the goal of training and nutrition, but rather the consequence. When your focus is on performing at your best—whatever your fitness goal might be—your appearance will come as a result.
It’s important to remember that everyone is different, and every body is unique.  
Appearance doesn’t define ability. Who cares whether you’re 10% or 15% body fat if you feel great, your personal performance improves, and you have a healthy relationship with food, training, and your friends and family? More importantly, what constitutes a healthy relationship with food and training? These are the questions you should ask yourself. 
It can be highly useful to track calories or macronutrients—proteins, fats, and carbs—but it’s important to understand and listen to your body. When you have hard training days, it’s vital to refuel adequately for recovery to prepare for the next one. Above all, eat with intention, and choose quality foods in the right amounts—all of which contribute to mission readiness. Feeling good, being able to recover and perform well, and maintaining a healthy body weight are all crucial to human performance optimization (HPO). 
Before Ironman race time, by being honest with myself, I was able to change my behavior and recover better from my workouts by gaining a bit of weight. I got over my injuries quicker, trained effectively again, and then was able to perform at my best. Sure, I didn’t feel as lean as I once had, but I began to perform better with a few extra pounds on me. When I reframed my goals—to pursue fitness, not just the appearance of fitness—I saw everything improve. Now I can approach my upcoming races with a new mindset.  
 
So, when it comes to preparing for a fitness goal, keep your goal in mind—the performance part—and let your appearance come as a side benefit of your fitness.  
 
For more information on tactical nutrition strategies, visit HPRC's website. For more personal information, contact a Registered Dieitian (RD), or Ask the Experts at HPRC.
 
About the Author

Greyson is a CHAMP HPRC intern and a Health Science and Psychology student at Clemson University. He has competed and coached in endurance racing, including Ironman Triathlon, road cycling, and trail running. He holds an American Council of Exercise (ACE) Personal Trainer Certification.
 
Disclosure: *The opinions and assertions expressed herein are those of the authors and do not reflect the official policy or position of USU or DoD. The contents of this publication are the sole responsibility of the author and do not reflect the views, opinions, or policies of The Henry M. Jackson Foundation for the Advancement of Military Medicine, Inc. Mention of trade names, commercial products, or organizations does not imply endorsement by the U.S. Government. The author has no financial interests or relationships to disclose.